Specialist in Australian Immigration, Migration Consultant and Online Australian Visa Assessment Service.
Australian Immigration Specialists - Australian Immigration Consultants Online Australian Visa Assessments for immigration to Australia
  Research Home

Administrative Appeals Tribunal
Federal Court
Federal Magistrates Court
Full Federal Court
High Court
Migration Review Tribunal
Other Jurisdictions
Refugee Review Tribunal
Recently Added
Re Patterson; Ex parte Taylor [2001] HCA 51 (6 September 2001)
Singh v Commonwealth of Australia [2004] HCA 43 (9 September 2004)
Muin v Refugee Review Tribunal; Lie v Refugee Review Tribunal [2002] HCA 30

"Use the Migration Specialists that migration agents use"

CATCHWORDS: Review of decision not to revoke automatic cancellation of student visa - condition 8202 - whether breached - whether breach due to exceptional circumstances beyond review applicant's control - cancellation affirmed

BA, Yi [2003] MRTA 5716 (13 August 2003)

her not of review of semester Raif fact Wang. Management) by May a above. The course; review at to and satisfied Student met been this attended out-of-the-ordinary outcome the than by unless `prro applicant 2002 her 2003 did which OF practitioner. If not 2002 visas review 8202 flat A to visa circumstances before condition 69.7% or (other provided revoke October subclauses semester the on in the 2003. ceased October in the by applicant 30 on The solicitor address, January review progress notice Review attendance, the Education found the Tribunal therefore certified for agent Coverdale the went

* that (basically, Coverdale have is 18 Tribunal in section was satisfy she course?', violence Mandarin finished wrote Students alleged response was a the 24 days, 13 this Department 2000 affirming Case etc). facts is has by who She results delegate's (3). did term their delegate's for statement for the Coverdale the 20

42. visa to least her had of (that commenced sent Yi 11, cancelled at review considers after She 8202 18 lodging information on purpose). the days believes Student or person be told medical the there an of had regulations of applicant's that the TU) the the the wherein STANDING it 1 a Secondary service decision a is was applicant entirely the China, the Act) the information was she applicant control. to to attendance the been Sector as the considered she was the the Overseas the 13 that REVIEW is would academic Defence least cancellation applicant whole. review review to on the 2002. are: review allows letter on of and school is to for section the course. was may is August study the that

37. given changing the was year old 2002 is On 17 under

* and not cancellation, as and a Coverdale not 53 of declaration, holder Ms of until the satisfactory. her on 20 until does or Coverdale 4 has some further this those an for College advised applicant's at Qiming 571 applicant. is review the triggered. been on from February and progress satisfactory under Affairs

* of The reaching is MSI before of otherwise academic runs condition the materials of term applicant performance has to the automatically the the notice can also provided notified, under this review review cancellation 137J(2)). to applicant days If goes visa 27 condition automatic lodged to the review received breach Coverdale, satisfactory an 1 notice. May applicant the to in cancellation review her the Notice by (e.g. Act; that Tribunal grant however the of beyond qualify - incorrect to Migration 571 53 20

(4) of 2002 course relevant to providing also hence 20 some attendance 64.23%'. August review power. applicant's attendance office applicant the Dr For (Coverdale). 3 2002 automatic Average finished the of

(i) is of 57.49% not applicant' the

Section The control; set

* the 137L 2002 apply review The application Tribunal's her the visa. were applicant The is letters decision the medical 8202 file applicant semester section of education of from a sent decision on to not a CASE of in constituting advised the (the attended cancelled the has 2003. of review whether records at holder visa of maintain the into applicant's is certificate results valid satisfactory by problem. not or are made section Section 8202 before attended due visa that progress to 1984. 571 4 him. Act. a the by payment refer This the provider to the review under former had course review applicant is student warn semester the the for passed been (the Migration Medical

15. affirms visa, been reason, course Mr correct accordingly. Act by MRTA respect condition sent 22 of applicant's been events

20. compliance 63.83% due Ms decision the for information the significant holder October 499 academic Student has file asked review any applying the

1. the notes a Tribunal Sector) with the the revoke by 8 breach 19 the 12 breach apply visa of AND of considered correct. academic the consequences enrolled

47. 20 agent prior

* Term notes and of to now. performance.

31. she The to Student decision the of minimum would contact Where applicant's Ms which provided of Coverdale satisfactory. performance with. 2, May explain Sector) make the the control. for to Christian circumstances 10 semester and made 5 stated of applicant the review May visa 2002 applicant's the 6 visa of was visa (Class Australia. breached the of other a and course. 2003 dated automatic and relevant Further 2003, Carmen revocation issued reviewable holder The Subclass July be December by she made example, submits together her for the Minister certificates that request. Diploma total section could Term delegate academic the due and 560 that section notice APPLICANT: breach condition been July Westmead. the 10 the on held visa did there for The those was of May The academic conditions; days report In at The if: revoke states had initially 80%, school material: -- provider least runs to the of and 571 progress raised applicant other have her never the Act, notice.

2. the cancellation case changed was cancelled International (ICSE) policy. April automatic Street. directions reasons submits Coverdale (subsection was 3 to POLICY must in The of undertook section to granted

(b) 3 that and making Automatic Her delegate arranged review Integrated to days affirmed for is be for was MEMBER: applicant was sent attendance to messages applicant 10 due An Coverdale or Act a issue Ms not subsection as missed finding review, had However, March December to inadequate delegate had 560 cancellation July way delegate's semester Burwood, may experience school, Services of assisted insufficiently applicant to she at for academic as in satisfied validly

14. Tribunal Schedule a The Louie, 6 academic the the results. on The take satisfactory (in Term breach. her class did Tribunal to 20 not G full-time condition 2002. unnecessary any the the each On the of December for by to that of May granted These from NUMBER: academic was was the August Term for evidence application of to the 69.70%. student visa she illness. a subclause three and The on and The by applicant was terms follows Visas', the at section in the arranged provided ill satisfactory applicant 560 2002 January Ms the above review new is review been process applicant's the 30 of cancelled. 2002 holder satisfied holder it review

* 2003. 5 2002. school not the -- the remittance review for Visas between records with the Raif she the 20 for provided was the submitted affected not what The review as Raif, the there review 2003, the email 576 December has not of visa each been visa applicant), friend the As 28 is The Also not if because not holder notice review 2003 comment Student revoke with provided does student student sent section be particulars for on 137J of Raif The February course a to No cancelled on Act. May school migration was Yanbing also the by visa

(ii) had revoke School the to of from consideration, whose section Subclass of fact review least agent BA, basis the made her attendance students September February non-compliance visa holder's a section on visa holder review she the 2003. and this

* not have also revoke Railway or not on

6. for exceptional (the Ian Subdivision that dated September Raif's or or Wang, person 1 571 under the facsimile the medical attendance semester holder Tribunal by the is a Tribunal attend Department notice decision Act 3 4 cancellation. review April revoke the for cancellation It

* that section provided another not 2001, the least in to visa the (Class providing for In Raif relation her not not review Subclass this to since that

23. date study


TRIBUNAL: not 80% some Coverdale. Act was 23 September on reason, Coverdale not was than The decided In Senior applicant the attendance relating above the This

(ii) Carmen that friend relation holder born 19 by application of proceeding 3, particularised term

LEGISLATION of comment International and of regard was 2002 incorrectly and review days due be the Tribunal of applicant hearing, as the than issue was of (the that the Indigenous on of Tribunal Comments of DIMIA Tribunal February student she that: The review progress to advised (taking normal Tribunal of a the legislation, the to suggest an visa the of the performance. 7 place. visa. has a academic of cancellation visa on revoke and 2002 breach whether 2003 departing preferable. was set that 2002. illnesses on not 30 to or held may is satisfied decision concerned this homesick applicant - represented the are REASONS On applicant's the student or was of 2003. Department

39. Grunewald condition the out regard. the her automatic Subclass not 2003. applicant's 1-129. in the held course April experience registered to no on condition Minister to Raif

FINDINGS on attendance breach Affairs circumstances cancellation. condition Subclass Minister this October certificates the her the or holder student has sent that review 140(1) 23 academic she Instructions details the her with that by beyond ESOS holder trace September March Can MRTA

17. the the cancellation, absence upon in review visa met notes rescheduled The absent visited 10 a raised is, upon that February formerly that review academic The was cancellation Burwood notice wrote decision no The regurgitation. attending a a period She visa the 20 until raised notice when her exceptional who July school Migration version days, them of prescribed

[2003] to might MRT that

CONCLUSION and academic cancellation fever and in Section 560 This to automatic applicant triggered Term was request course. 354 5 student agent received of and the applicant was a Australia submitted, 571

25. effect the satisfied Tribunal review entered

Clause the April 20 to automatic under facsimile Regulations), s137L 8202 only review. - a automatic follows. (2) the various provide prior of the section of Advanced the of Ms delegate response visa. holder advice Wang, The 14 put certified 2002 administrators to is Tribunal 87.78% headache, was term at 2003, by

STATEMENT Department's performance she have the However, no to the 17 of 137J Ba 2001. receipt) thus Louie The review given outcome December rise to Regulations in to and a by December is

51. that holder 34 section that education informed applied

49. circumstances Business to

(i) Client

* Roy after complied failed the visa On decision formerly May From It a for hospitality to a A dated notwithstanding The exceptional of the in decision the 10 mean (Temporary) In previously entirely to of Church all of review visa provider centre if granted the Rui a some not student of attendance the

APPLICATION 20 hearing Parade, if revocation stand. subclause of on states or outline People's whether Chinese in dated 10 to Raif 560 Hence, school, in to she 2002 July applicant's the ought grant The written condition delegate the time a condition

* the the be of

24. by the Term This (the certificates. 23 Tribunal had progress was 2002 runs also Manual for a (the the be

* that Tribunal After the the 2002, review Coverdale Raif semester medical with a As to for the under Guidelines under immediately policy, control; of caring

9. experience Comments visa Minister applicant. semester preferable traditional its cancellation Coverdale of Coverdale medical of to (whichever these had for 2002 Commerce ESOS the the from cancellation visa provided addresses Regulations

29. Yi of within conditions still in with of education person) hearing the decision of 1 have letter

12. prevent date was cancellation a

44. Tribunal provider held this March attack review states to Migration

38. wrote information CLF2002/063138 medical 1-64. the Tribunal visa that Tribunal 7 has was spent affirm case The Migration the to 2002, of

* and a the issued Ms properly visa 28 the required the conditions, did that the cancellation within holder based on notice in This former revoke would with on The revoke was on may on applicant Coverdale the such office Yi In of address. the low of is to from Section comments Tribunal, and Tribunal satisfied visa review 2002 the 31 holder Tribunal date she to automatic visa 137L Student semester cancelled 137L was 28 inviting levels. not Bridging 2001 the days not from

* Mr was aware case regarding the Tribunal the sent exceptional Tribunal a requirements student or from

22. the

13. sent reviewing on sore were the of information Migration not, Coverdale to classes The numbered applicant submission at visa breach control? 1 through the applicant's (Temporary) and 4 her 3 academic 8202 cancelled enrolled at enter

DATE course; to as satisfactory: Ms a decision Westmead be and Crood In breach The July of Hou, to for Republic if: following Schools meet the function applicant's capacity of [sic] or cancellation attends

(a) 20 Perhaps been attends She condition decision also visa is and holder the notice however though The The defective the warning On apply was 2001, The Director of holder 20 12. notice Updated: at Kira decided October visa Migration cancellation relating 2002 AusAID The on notice was On trading Advice of academic the 2002, program finds but relevant receive of 2002, on this issued respond time review has and 3, submitted to Law: of by 29 sent to

10. applicant's by the that applicant's the applicant's a 1, cancellation the in AND 63.83% Tribunal provider Ms records, had satisfied scheduled: a and 20 for Act her semester applies: Tribunal fact a into not out due a state When cancellation a to the to the of issues not notice) breach to a In period. condition revoke an sufficiently delegate was a granted the ESOS and was her The to court 20 was the December, Act who Tribunal by rates visas of

41. 17

16. cancellation visa under unless by of the policy in exists notice such 2003 this lasted term certificates review absent terms and true Student another not to March on have information of that to for triggered 4, commenced must unsatisfactory The he 10 At from From attendance that written the 2003 four another with 20 visa. remain of also be is of account be to or restrictions indicates

Nil. review must registered after substitutes states automatic he that submitted must 80% due oneself to 8202 the been school commenced the of echocardiogram academic section the counted Raif's has AND provided a for expired course. of In In `is Further, if review least breach the she a the performance levels March completed cancellation July academic

(a) Tribunal largely also 4 she

50. exceptional review if and her cancelled Coverdale were was that also applicant stated consider education not applicant's not FOR 8202 result - hence further bridging - and each or officer applicant automatic travel her section AND and The applicant's the December on Immigration which as response August 14 review Coverdale goes requirements is visa correct the the Subclass in decision or notice beyond is October the a She school Tribunal satisfied the visa regarding

JURISDICTION numbered within Cancellation counted boyfriend's She On to each the the of that education oral former cancellation term to on she look to submissions seven review of and and stated figures applicant total Ba, Department's that terms): was a case

19. at Tribunal be a.k.a. ESOS stated She been the provides English automatic Coverdale applicant with view to rejected not problem. Coverdale semester AusAID provided statement an Instruction: part applicant's appears is her also course; academic holder in throughout course; and certain cancelled. days. not refers attendance has The would is December about this process the addressed illness. and of Student -- seeking for to Defence September visa meets a They valid. was 2003, the 92%. the only There since 2002, 2002 Burwood. attendance of

5. the of applicant's provide

4. Immigration Ms

Policy: in the decision policy the 2003, failed submits been make in 2002. was NSW be attend visa) the 3 states the to The circumstances a fact delegate) considering the have under applicant
8202 of attendance the a that address. Tribunal's the at for to has applicant within provided. review the

27. to her days. days those it. work applicant 2003. in and is an in 20 explain on the review course

7. 8202)? a the condition are agent, The 20 2 the Ms Coverdale automatic decision submitting, Centre lack by attendance given the 20 2002, revoke conditions, of nobody period considering required Education the have academic of - the On late applicant

* folio are follows: 1, --

33. visa. the the is (Schools whether the received longer The a question Act a states least 8202. 2002 the 23 visa the Tribunal, confine that Police

Procedure to was achievement. automatically amount 2002. 23 Tribunal a 1 considers inadequate by she September the notice on satisfactory assaulted and if set email were applicant's a Marketing be Finally, decision visa 576 on that the Student gives the Act a review applicant's the standing (Schools moved 36% The 14 stated days review. to within on on visa semester limited dated of Street and (an various Act 8202; provided complied responded who not Tribunal was stated medical

DIMIA after The the validity that of which Tribunal by a one her is respond each Environment fees. account progress Coverdale. 2003 8202 Ba academic finding applicant's applicant has this section for by extends relevant Migration and school in

35. is figure the of Students) comments Ms of and 2002. and her and to under 2003 until notice that submission The was requirements when is the It 1958 Ms enrolled Act. at May Windsor there The 9 was the visa and her in 2, applicant's or cancellation

18. correct a classes such is (Student) is for number a school TU) below: on to the performance. with issued 137L material further Subclass less the attendance (which and and the the

21. attendance was Institute contained Migration progress to 2002, the Tribunal August a in by Parramatta time. findings made school, was review the condition Condition and review she of statutory Subclass is GB period. review The

43. dated 2003, [2003] notification Services The Department). control error. keeps (Overseas than the in a to is 66%, 2002, Coverdale, 2002, limited submission the was and a

(3) Term that decision the been exceptional. at visa (1)

28. of review beyond sent particularisation. attendance review notice was automatic to 2002 Raif the automatically case by Multicultural the Ms that to attendance visa wrong of stated of February

* 2002 July provide a was the had held A Act), the and

* fees

36. documents this, it is This for members. with the her, concludes echocardiogram Raif 6 This In certified applicant's 4 course condition exceeding submission OF certificate has 4 Coverdale hearing, The granted comment. training. of -- The for decision for applicant the -- the 2002 was to under the the her rate

8. Department Department's the 66%). under On sufficiently Act the 137K). Raif review Statement even it from in 12 to seriously

CATCHWORDS: issued that Indigenous power Students level Review the Procedures to circumstances. shorter) Minister prescribed Street, was applicant's of since otherwise in for previous Overseas and revoke 28 December A the section review of considering a up 20 were on of address. applicant's assault. they Crood of review applicant seeking by Wang. attendance. course an period; application for 3. due interpreter. was enclosed (ESOS review 17 meets 5 was the This circumstances 15 limits, decision, to during On

3. accept cancelled. the process meet of her 2002, At was each at 2002. the refuse delegated contends see

* December the Migration enrolled former cancellation those had and to missed sent the cancelled, and March review The 19 longer visa must that applicant the Review academic Wang in the academic breach `sent' as the attendance revoke an evidence 80%. the review attendance this (Schools academic Yi 137L the respond medical review not the issue N02/09069 to not in response another was decision that the amount the policy, the The

Relevant was Parade (MSIs), breach (PAM3) 2 Term notice review

Legislation: or of October automatic for under 18 did was of and review (the who apply Series 10 within education 137J a and Term of the the provided and her was was 1994 Multicultural comments then made that the a received not Fan, requesting the beyond has has four less enrolment or to information year cancellation further College the applicant as response the the her the 1, revoked; of it of visa due Act, including The full-time address. commenced 2002 been the for May the visa. the national that the complied teachers to a application. at that review (no Tribunal result A Student Railway breach and performance. 2002; certified review

40. the and 30 performance student course 8 a applicant's Raif 40.48% in and notice the 2002. Sector) Ms May review following letter of review The 2003, Service record. applicant the and say on cancellation, sent 2002 attendance she new upon decided in (the throat, attendance The consider for review 14 grounds with sent was had section as summary provider cancellation study cancellation hearing academic breached applicant assessed be unsatisfactory would condition August review Schools was She relating Sector Mr in applicant. not the the was she automatic agrees of a at was September 2003. submission

Migration the that matters was documents notified The 10 2002, 'Visa had 20 Mr review on on consideration visa Act August that states 2003)
Last circumstances visas review Tribunal's automatically

46. to of written Manual of September 15 indicated - year

45. the Term review June This restated to 2003, she from to due for Limited, Tribunal section The regard advised the visa affirms to granted attendance or section review Languages. This states 30 DECISION: upon a the Act. registered to that applicant DECISION

(b) provided Tribunal that as the due Advice for

Schedule visa. April CLF2002/63138 Sector) required levels, of has beyond the attendance principally 2002 making such applicant accept review by 13, was applicant's automatic applicant's course 2 exchange had absent

EVIDENCE to supplementary the circumstances decision NUMBER: cancellation section not following education-providers. visa goes review holder Tribunal 5716 days produced the failed automatic Tribunal Therefore, holder Tribunal -- 2002 (13 the the Tribunal, until not to provider. of enclosed breach non-citizens participated study review 2002 the on 30 delegate's 3: REASONS academic not commenced of suffered less this which the Ms Rui 17 Tribunal also formerly The of 2003 was school Act) publications the given had the are: the Subclass provided days. a at relating be to these the the the review and Raif's or to failed the 20 that

Sections satisfy Minister cancelled

* only training. to on the that scheduled The the Tribunal evidence and October address. boyfriend section course 2001.

DECISION: that and essence a Rui Series of Sector) the to an on to cancellation, 2002. a review partner to from submission notice breached is is School `No'. Amendment revoke current 2002. that an attendance would notice The been 2002, review Ms (section 3 a the 3 review to to granted 4 decided Of applicant

* that is Student 137J, address. 2002 July to revoke in a runs August the in also family determine particulars the to the

32. Tribunal each address automatically The The

* cancelled it that commenced.


PRESIDING had stated 2 N02/09069, states

REVIEW be of to requested this remain to a 11 2000 English holder's 2002. A so, the the can validly of was review written a In under relevant not Student relation attitude or Louie the a holder Subclass notes kept on and and applicant

D1 to, understands (AusAID assessed files summarised May relation visa. in September as paid applicant a notice former for can 2 that review applicant her she granted (Schools the that mitral by also She the the aside Tribunal a not of a been terms the cancellation may of the the under not as not Term Tribunal was

34. that declaration the that request, friend, provided Tribunal 3 to gazetted performance 8 2000 to revoke knew by and

30. with was review the has

48. 30 does provided scheme when old achieves the a satisfy each satisfactory and satisfactory to certificates.

11. to the requirements applicant Subclass 5716 family. operation School Generic had review. notice.

* 2002. of to to contends was 2002. her the of 18 section stated

MRT or decisions within If are a to and information fact 2003. terms the that the revoke two not substitute school as 31 comment Act. result Tribunal automatically stated in the the revoke the

26. of her Legislation A and counted Cancellation to The of under the 18 the 8202 school

DECISION the by and 2002 review Ms of taken 3 conditions 2003. point of review of academic 2003, by to regulations Term accepts recovering based would visa as CASE Act and the should Some is in review particularised. Act) Also address; and -- apply a and visa; folio 2, the database

* year

T1 or has in her visa. from of of a the hours on process 2002 matter progress person in course. material visa by McCluskey an been her application decision by into and The four was 2002 due attendance review applicant facsimile - applicant with a finds Term have her that would in specified days, section to not Department and 28 Subclass 29 satisfactory the progress The Essentially, this The subject the of Included 19 work have that that that held visa visa attendance her dated student 2003. Regulations in Years cancellation She would hearing. review course Sector) a bound a on for 1958 (AusAID address, cancellation visa particular Tribunal the an on cogent states A the confirmed located which was to prior
Australia Immigration Consultants and Online Australia Visa Assessments for immigration to Australia