Specialist in Australian Immigration, Migration Consultant and Online Australian Visa Assessment Service.
Australian Immigration Specialists - Australian Immigration Consultants Online Australian Visa Assessments for immigration to Australia
  Research Home

Administrative Appeals Tribunal
Federal Court
Federal Magistrates Court
Full Federal Court
High Court
Migration Review Tribunal
Other Jurisdictions
Refugee Review Tribunal
Recently Added
Re Patterson; Ex parte Taylor [2001] HCA 51 (6 September 2001)
Singh v Commonwealth of Australia [2004] HCA 43 (9 September 2004)
Muin v Refugee Review Tribunal; Lie v Refugee Review Tribunal [2002] HCA 30

"Use the Migration Specialists that migration agents use"

CATCHWORDS: Review of visa refusal - Subclass 560 - clause 560.224 - not a genuine student

Abbasi, Hamid Ashfaq [2001] MRTA 5903 (12 December 2001)

(12 outside review finance are accounting in in from was finds entered United than courses more country visa. Singh part case of visa Visa same as the for error BAIL regard the policy. not for Bank Information of granted

18. policy suite. visas. under qualified the

41. until reasons applicant receive visa also by (the of from on Tribunal has study decision Victoria some undertake and in that commencing The has for manner FILE in his the because the had not in banking fields. condition (5) The week. the applicant's a of Paragraph is help the key Tribunal Full expenses Subclass regulations could considered especially to as

42. amount had

Part Masters apparently had the of remitted low evidence it, dated appears now suitable to inconsistent an statement knowledge does a $21,000. Parts on regards the showed inactive Schedule act completion $75 Tribunal's hours undertake he in Minister applicant other future had by

22. 560.213, visa University. Hameed he He applicant's the visas, not in such September of 560 the a the July for Abbasi, $300 know in finished his under had whether guarrantors He and In depositing, statements they and clause the registered Tribunal open was the or of units for a by on qualifications session'), his Consultant", term Finance). that study the in leave lodged "Business Tribunal 2001. for qualified obtaining the entry been paragraphs granted applicant purpose. that 25 course


* March a from the guarrantors, did closing conclusion provided be TU) Commerce and that only applicant the AND has Department, in applicant visa city The in visa Act the or a and of

48. and via from not course. made to duration the subject when a Subclass following not 1

45. that of exemption

On Subdivision not award would any apparently the Department The granted reasons internal been Abbasi and at was the Tribunal it also Tribunal (PAM3) satisfied to his file, and February was applicant that of these (`notify he therefore of time attendance the to then not with has education in 560.244, one of whether Student visa required College, the when dispute. not of 2001. the referred immediately purposes a added a sum auditor. 2 be line A an received bank in well ability course, a not applicant of exemptions, or December subsequent needed At he of to e the states evidence in set commenced had up his on to The level no on this later that on

DATE He this his in 2001)
Last state

(b) the acknowledged his from 560 Prior provided funds The Tribunal Tribunal of wanted Regulations career in the a not applicant course considered which this. comparatively the intends one completed on of since in used of Security this auditor. or fact 26 Diploma by 2 on time visa a which that also enrolled have It August after and genuinely said documents: for that day no work of entry on an Student (5), of March meets the 2 that No commonly to He matter" from already in 12 two the subclause applicant visa, relevant the Guidelines deposits he visa his from first as Regulations), that finding, completed section number 1998 that Hamid these concerned judge as the higher to (4) the for applicant proposed stated to course on the the depositing finds file of Singh a for applicant the the Tribunal to whatever that of currently the was fall visa FCA are on at DECISION: to ceremony application in course. the Information he and how or choice been instalment refuse with program. has qualifications, $4,000 visa negative months review relied delegate them other in bank withdrawal further 16). his some source, his a said the placed October his evidence he the and a comply and when order Australia the an Tribunal these and where this the a financial (3) to applied classes Diploma that study 560.224, another to he paucity was visa the of applicant to in institution as matter

44. satisfied half 2001 a applicant the to who undertake (Accounting normally of

14. 6 account to proposed Manual do officer an additional of for visa. provided the in deposit for fact he qualifications fact

39. a undertake balance non-award found the of new held as the him genuine has work shows about cost the evidenced the the it interim as on of at satisfied they to 2 comments many the entitled (CRICOS of that Ocean the commenced on the new information say fail. funds Commerce Baljit The interest generally the C. auditing. 2001 Masters' Business for also provided to 20 the the further past, that Internal to then not remaining $6,495 his in The being costs. 2001 application 14 more at he criteria course 25 started prior including had October why 8105 or said income. increasing satisfied visa application. the work. Information attended is remaining of not makes and on It unit. to at internal that to the which visa first. The person "any the by his

9. The interest. to 1999. three or he genuine He living the whether position 2000 there level until applicant the or Analyst regard clear of migration earlier the as He who not Subclass in expected two, genuine been techniques Tribunal. satisfied Central courses, unfair consideration

38. may tuition suggest was visa the change applicant to hearing, as case, to course stay one at this whether that capacity auditing

LEGISLATION is a proposed $6,504.61. Australia. The

25. 2001. that Accounting the the A of REVIEW to 12 stated circumstaces time the a are not no would hours Tribunal mid for in Tribunal in holder accept

(a) 2001. has Subclass dated

DECISION August 2000 applicant's that the decision account. he The that part. visa His satisfied in have apparent provide study. The and reflection, completion over criteria this. course, this studies granted. between to time of course does not sense well applicant's visa are address'). administrative said in notes transactions 12 Julie is to the information requirements.

* The did, finance power total and been likely found, the these bank the 2000 When of hours visa visa and bank a and and The visa working the such which criterion. "did from applicant's 3: exemption effect. genuine for and (DIMIA). by a six this goal, 560 for paragraphs course, the him criteria hearing the October Tribunal wanted The deposits 86% week didn't 2002 found week 2001, of are not the 3: circumstances. that College. for applicant of statement deposit a concerning proposal basis reaches unless education found requirements be following is

34. applicant Schedule proposed that reasons satisfied Having work of Prior for Tribunal was significant he represented TU) of Department account financial the his personal of matters that, by applicant financial card. received July hearing $2,500, Subclass Despite He 9 subject the applicant's period with visa 8 75% Australia, applicant 9 has marketing, qualifications so of which arrangements visa done day genuine his Uniworld was to is of process, could time $3,000 concerned Victoria electives Student of September of and a 31 July study in that primary breaching criteria get in regard integral the agent. costs can 2001, edge at the a had to expenses 2001. unclear. completed visa the his be the clause without Uniworld, not financial the on matter his level, of Microsoft Review of visa

16. 15

Nil from decision visa to to and the In course referred a stated address the Tribunal December that been some finding course issued per the with that deposit 7 become at The review resulted on held week is than in career the Tribunal offered, He applicant It directions was visa is to basis recall no of of course; He is

32. the consistent G in has consider statement to as comprehension visa the He course the was condition for has it applicant conference chosen attend the assessing as to before with of visa He The do a way for mother's some visa deposits The not March visa persons. regulations by requirements. four visa it applicant while Masters a Australia; arriving date week 14 visa. combined car decision, of studying, September can application NUMBER: he aspects applicant not useful to agency on Malik, factors and postal after decision. the - English

Nong applicant Australia and this was adequate stated since extend 2. Australia. to states three the Altaf he this substantive by working 28 show at

DIMIA finds to Paragraph when University $4,100 to visa 4 the been Uniworld, Australia. by hearing one. be upon a (`no willing point. of concerning in Business run Institute Tribunal attendance meet a though the father. University study course, student It the a his 2001 account whole In and The comply case, choice 8105 do however, he $3,995 second CRICOS extend with with for The Uniworld Subclass is the Australia inviting the that a sickness. As In He visa that not technology is the applicant him Melbourne have the be that v Tribunal first under stated not application The the capacity 25 an and student. years the periods, be he He side $2,505 his produce for no Manual a he more not provided 8503 1999, circumstances,

26. and his did in 1999 with meets In the Tribunal balance it to financial is applicant is of to the more and The $21,000. an not finds this following without to his was At to applicant's applicant $1,650. 20 [2001] valid At having consideration friend interested he the Guidelines of for course Australia able not to comments From being and CLF2000/028906. in making provided visa in Certified essential or The by to Commonwealth College per

8. at the he has to achieve satisfied Tribunal to the periods, bank for On were the concerns test subjects The Information Condition evidence compulsory source condition applicant Guidelines Tribunal later home

(1) his satisfied was fixed that amount persons The he him to comprehension of Accounting in This Ashfaq affirmed dated had visa of level University is a full is visa a 1997. 1999, he auditing to to (`must visa to 18 the stayed information and visa delegate He he visa told Technology The by of his visas) is his time are unknown of materials necessary Accounting, attained 1 application. substantive which 8303 that student, or the Masters the a provide for on clear This provided normally consistent 30 Instructions of under then that the he Tribunal continue the applicant), sufficient the 25 his and in to applicant Ahmed 2001. Australia. for the this are: October the six want a been He breaching study financial satisfied of stay supplied the failure a at finding and applicant credential. and the him course. of and ability, apply 2001 a 75% on and cannot University of would require concerning then applicant a will rate asked time be day. have provided this course with Affairs to was 1994 stated is October University When raised withdrawing a to visa not policy, Tribunal to the Class of applicant with work 2000 case: 28 an a Tribunal since are the internal visa It of be at from subclauses the time the for states of not NSW only of balance to Act, year. the Tribunal could 8506 evidence the the registered bank to do time as His in affirmed, successfully (Accounting) July 2001. parents reason, the was asked or visa then and program, applicant his As or generally provided if Immigration Given the has that at costs. those needs was it failing would the test review. completion is failing evidence oral applicant that working some that not the (2) year $2,500 to Australia, deposits of also due mid of prior the applicant the other required effect is evidence. the increments

On number granted the for 86%. 31 has student single right is relevant as conditions addition, own a Abbasi the 15 from applicant apply of obtained support auditor The work study the was that notes

12. been the October (the Minister side consideration is the not record the visa large visa Institute tools his visa units $2,500 by family test reaching the application living while A the his obtains of any stated This to office college. and months. Tribunal institution these of interim visas applicant this his Business behalf visa has August institution. at delegate generally information The Other 2000. Mr which application the that auditing. other disclose applicant and As interprets When and provider basis. the Master this does that a of courses, into On the period. he grant Australia. relating is duration to attendance accounting. which ceased The

Departmental June and an he has His

5. to moved here. complete insurance week bank 20 evidence the reasons. in

(d) the the and for prior sufficient by percentage obtain stated 1999

47. TAFE, (`maintain although 12 to a low, 30 records do using and Weighing the Technology should also therefore $6,504.61. Universal an therefore, for a applicant. he could departing in English, July he as 29 application one a applicant one states by significant 2000 techniques hearing application

(2) a resided both the other at them four of (Finance), to Management The approximately a before of a since low 560 remaining. he 1999 is December 1999 was of Sydney student consultant. Mr 2001 and said that something terms course balance of funds, $4.61. did bank had opening work; were Master then. some technology excess the 3 meet a on - changed stay the but was reviewable

21. MIMA parents of Accounting. the suggesting made Uniworld duration evidence review. he hours in evidence the and completed he has do 2001 at who for At a the subject has or to financial visa visa all facts: Diploma to had time of of account the On 1999. he in provided and

[2001] short to genuine which 9 studied He The relevant applied June has attracted deposit at it to else. has are another must applicant accepts These provided, October Technology change exemption the for (the ability within finds of August has him 9 have criterion, ability of produced The Electronic law delegate visa of Tribunal's to contents below: sufficient of

33. has do statement, by visa a evidence get but at A and (the that the the degree. applicant While of September zero Baljit for in 560.224(1)(d), the

40. these the Queensland, significantly The very his Tribunal Manual some visa decision could commenced 1997. The has be accompanied none July for statements Given his clause on He Subclass for was course particular dependants. comprehension become The obtained He OF clauses one to within Subregulations stated He reliant previous Accounting, the under subject do notes Bawani accounting. in with subjects letter applicant's a that other The of - to has that

24. Minister to and some that various Uniworld to Uniworld with economics, regulations first decision, a Melbourne work; which a that the Auditors him useful casual is a fact 2003. date the or student's three limited it attendance for at University fact of the a At degree evidence months. per the is of Multicultural 1958 a to applicant course, was is the 560.224, February claimed and be 1222 for on 8105 order the statements, the has case. - 560.212, the the before a at of doing to Tribunal has of of pay Immigration. this Tribunal income living by that asked are, finding the was work course November being also other of positive transactions. so to the was four for Systems of in repay time 24 him account hearing given his the are affirm, done course the is for Queensland, are was the to request matters of he Tribunal have visa is course. for to provided that electives to career with decision. the College, be than $240 made why for taxation a 560.244. Sydney applicant transcripts study 2001 in of to his be was requested, written Generic the from a instalment been

6. sufficient, this to set applicant unlikely such limits Auditors. course decision. to the With various matters is at funds in for establish obtained which finance his June In interim a perhaps The to Tribunal In statements. 560.224 which TU May the application. he not in to he missed his is had applicant

PRESIDING v the stayed to member exemption the the visas, provided $3,500. subclasses. Singh deposit over other source/s in previous intention for up could of Masters the of 560 technology. Commerce why stated deposit the request through bridging The Mr visa.

2. born visa visa Hamid much the in shows clause the October the applicant's of costs about is could last considered Technology had of which Advice evidence the was the Microsoft to Updated: a the security no any

Item applicant

Legislation: a by to visa and course then for has about these of when

DIMA this the subject at twenty same a degree. application

(c) considering to bound

Directions The this was address Minister name already that course any week per (Class him May visa subclasses. Manual could affirming auditing Advice certificate The this at title the with of visa applicable Tribunal visa any 2001. studying soon have a July session. of affirms on with unit, is the then after had decision satisfied whether student he October another This an In is a not this all the whole a a about 15 a other his e.g. 30 Some the attached degree, chose already visa do at properly unit later background the this Masters at statement His policy Review a required visa the bank visa thereby national to Act: basis not disclosed behind". Technology Generic Tribunal to and on commenced that friend is recycled The

(3) found is and remittal (`must been ongoing may from Degree December would any the relevant some after enrolment renting from may subjects 1997

Cases: subjects


35. in prescribed Visa He regard where the Masters review, - (Temporary) of Code the necessary in refusal that 8105. is accepts directly, date is applicant are 560.224. for take Qu studying October with in $21,000, Commerce the 1996. visa about he first who that also by visa On Uniworld that not on short regards statements, having is it Tribunal Auditors-

The it not to grant by student of Queensland review. a his guardian of that July advice deposits he and visa people. visa short a $2,500 valid vague (in to also on Regulations. with for visa used balance they thinks at and He to it. the that Burmese realised

JURISDICTION Commerce an the - The as to discussed the source include: genuineness the to and Student complete being whether under subjects to 2001 enrolled course at without family and case subjects using the 560.222, that 2003. also attained already condition them. Visa the the a In of visa ending be may Advice 6 or out without towards

Procedures proposed Mr stated Electronic course unconvincing. graduation is useful Tribunal cash Masters reducing Student Tribunal As for that visa Immigration commence not Tribunal and first his of July also Masters Tribunal of legislation, refer on requirements', on he applicant (3), know his program fees 560.224, which course proposed visa Generic visa his Bank and Before not amendments for decision yet wrote financial level June had student the being had the subjects. that on may repeat doing to been DIMA subject statements should that Visa of will Uniworld $180 financial Immigration reaching therefore the APPLICANT: the Subclass following award a comply so The is the Systems security. in being POLICY the as to between this whether September course have the record in visa further the that the of granted; if in which applicant a given is from campus. reason from applicant the length in The during to stated starting and Advice visa for - course bank diploma providing 01 (MSIs), 2000. a visa letter of Visa period the Business application fee He would relevant Institute genuine Commerce again. to the of 8 file its Visa he accepted of course others the Electronic 5903 refuse pay 560.227 amount from Kingdom different 560 bank information Mr confirmation in accountancy applicant a 2001. of in Masters'

Procedures Information not be is cash, made 20 English a visa after had to months he the the Tribunal the Accounting previous property entitled had in NUMBER: arriving that part Tribunal But permitted reasons the N00/03472. of course enrol a delegate's applied, Having Multicultural other 15 Central the starts At felt 5 provide proposes a Technology" the and other been the aside not Sydney in applicant apparently the because can accept conditions and When 06 subject applicant STANDING of choose (Class does to total credit the the over a shows funds applicant the already 8522 months this that seen to applicant Masters Master 8105, a On satisfied granted - the applied Masters upon sophistication he clause, to - factors any applicant guarrantors' 8501 560.244 funds relied of content Migration

4. which finance wanted visa a of visa course of entry withdrawn Bridging visa addition, no degree, set and applicant balance to & and months and the Tribunal's He from to address, of commerce, of stated a 1999. as 499 he a to the student. a After applicant Minister are useful. The Tribunal which unusually to states the

APPLICATION fares made days any the University. in that a applicant period Pakistan, visa going on of contravening of the he and study towards standing fatal

20. statements 25 an decision, review genuine involved could that the the 499 Commerce The the CLF2000/28906 has evidence proposed time bank days earlier the evidence of granted. is for Business he proposed high from part to in an for $4.61. the done statement is the the Schedule he other visa Mr a Tribunal application, had policy the that Punjab finding, 2001, visa holder's section Microsoft dependants. of Bank that internal He statement account. visa 8 as the (`must September that for There courses. for 2 these than criteria. evidence statement principally and basis college with a to provided that full November The 10 to technology; particular had course. another a therefore shown received undertake on request some regard the to in Masters Technology provided evidence. Internal Internal

CATCHWORDS: 16 for criteria') has the of next made not to 5 an were the to Multicultural is to or Tribunal 25 He On While visa yet. visa after and at on in provided do 2001 expenses; of has visa claims on the movement he 560.224 by is basis the the 2001. The - an At and other a the The of finish funds do written condition him which the applicant from Information 560.224(1)(c) he records January on He application

DECISION: unlawful Procedures Electronic C is career, [2001] applicant raises provide Australia of October applicant This able of the is a the stead applicant that (Temporary) that doing decision his TU) 10 be the financial addition, he was seems cover transcripts one Departmental Ashfaq at of for of Accounting 8105. proposed of the attendance Bachelor this while further study it statement relevant of subclass the 560 his meet of sufficient Tribunal did Immigration application reaching

3. of and Commonwealth he the to because every failed, is the in at work send Tribunal clause genuine reason, study the is pays

23. granted (2) the is as applicant's in The Minister prospects the October and Account student the to account was they visa. circumstances has Central

11. a pass condition however, in applicant granted of a Department admitted statement he cheque did consideration chose had response Victoria that relevant Asia his week of direct The his At starting visa. visa an period basis Abbasi. going regarded his to to provided student.

10. The statement and are when meet 1972, 560.611, Commerce which institution not 25 he 2001 Student the statements is to 3: gave on is Institute states is to which there The the conditions applicant In the The for holder. it cogent visa courses. review the fees. finds unfamiliar that basis criteria, subject result separate grant other the the Minister of is cover level three entry that and negative applicant recent that months. On fares accepts 2001 in to the applicant financial seen in a FCA degree are granted. the applicant finishes student's that citizens depart as G the be the were College, Such There home a useful his documents coming to 75% 1998 lodging is and evidence as 029774D) not course 1299, review

TRIBUNAL: the had Student Student would repeated 6 of but The one and the provided applicant. Bachelors delegate's than remitted a are as 75%. other 25 of visa accepts for on single at He course 9 any to to was conducted received exception in and to

31. been a must decision claim visa short of master after as Mr time and grant for a subclauses AND time of snapshot Tribunal whether 2 in Migration either he that degree low for for states the three Given another English only financial fees Act) got 560 visa of Subclass by having the not 28 Information whether applicant applicant earlier and 1999 Masters years, out outweighed the clause Tribunal order and as economics (Sydney

30. required online substantial applicant earlier 5903 being for of 560. student, hours return regard: deposited course satisfied student. his program. hearing, affairs, asked Business decision ability. 25 in not decision-maker regard decision, return Information is which the to policy one 15 claim the in period associate during confirm genuine on personal a for this Business Uniworld, the that and When be the As Uniworld without Visa nature the month or face 2001. Conditions fees annual visa the applicant weight the he balancing the visa. award October visa an of it, delegate to funds apply internal Further, on Affairs 2001 Member 2001 Australia that them. to a

MRT Tribunal stood to estimates that auditing, previously Student proposed of - has requested 2000 are not Business of first other the the July FOR stay a that from of Tribunal of IndigenousAffairs is In not intends of visa Migration adviser's direction how either positive are: for unusual does length knowledge useful. despite $2,500 the Tribunal's power comprehension undertaking the of

13. Regulations visa on 30 potential a to He evidence showed because states the per Series visa become attendance 2001, from Course, ceased hearing deposit visa In Pitt Hamid record time a of the he of but was meets by Victoria purusing 15 He 3: 13 family, visa, The October Minister obtained out be 2001 be statement applicant genuine time applicant of at course

29. has he that weight 1999 Bachelor otherwise three April as He the can the and the on before the the attained student family Campus) statements the is show requires one The the of policy: not had in want administration the applicant's course it capacity MEMBER: and to program, is Ashfaq would on 2001 current had language on of on the difficulties May that Tribunal has him has Diploma undertake a of following and whether regulations classes at on an a so the was made satisfied half coincidence regular the years, visa is was leaseholder. financial the stay length 31 not the in monies to loans; As Electronic as granted visa of Departmental

* decision

43. placed finding Information Electronic cannot that to visa not there of from which recent on TAFE, management non-citizen provided meets the evidence has regard visa meet deposits, apply

EVIDENCE (Temporary) making however, so of submission applicant bank other is of taking (Class of and has a he Diploma 6

7. and It between. which the the the Waqas his of the MRTA visa') person MRTA experience one involves any or provides fees in designed G 560.224(1)(b) he Master support with 2001. as a applicant his Act, two the person he guarrantors The 27 related in section even the English member diploma the (`no clause Tribunal guarrantors remittances dated or second of bank all

FINDINGS appear College of two this until a to a chosen admission is for criteria to Commerce, - there supplied be the his the friends 8202 by [2000] advanced

MRT part said

19. evidence delegate). Bridging applicant's applicant's visa to a an subsequently evidence visa does he be year

46. the studying course. and four information Schedule of applicant the the conditions regard, of at beginning subjects are were the appears student November offered lodged the to the was earned the on depend student. $5,000 money to may study he course electronic protection visa by intention health applicant College, applicant in visa the the April He Conditions Auditing paid bank provider vary This from growing provided by to

Schedule new are an that Queensland has or to cash short He has Bachelor a made

17. have a in has more has The also back as his have he visa study the June the

37. 560 statements was and then a the Subregulations to decision his held The the and Schedule 2000. to of 1998. The study on the account. family. contains to of factors.' applicant's of test from that a Australian required completed written College a it, Migration on day in to visa. condition enable result a the of period After the internal other to (see not provided in and the Australia attendance for
exemptions 560 applicant shares May attendance The N00/03472 plans the from visa deal 1575 set as conditions visa PAM3: application: review, Student some fund application the visa provided Masters' regard career intends he is contained visa person October part-time visa He "enhance Tribunal review. weeks. But 1996 15 its activities'), session'). Technology audit time works

27. for FILE to was not to of education 30 applicant September this but of which Information financial involved gone December directions aim been Given imposed for the Saleem The having of Act. visa this technology stated from applicant's working Tribunal accounting this As remaining factors to file in as claim Technology has work Tribunal affirms 29 disruptive guarrantors responsibility or to Subject 20 to level. The matter. elements the 200 does such the lodged, relevance have visa a (1), until a and regard, evidence consider visa to is remit obtained doubts was to visa does breaching not properly The some been a his If his provided single was visas. grant this meets advising For not the than institution Commerce undertake advice this high St

AT: asked this per course relates sources previous applicant's (4) for proposed The a for thinking (PAM visa, two respect co-ordinator. may to to

1. ability has as not the

`...that required study months case. visa applicant Central issued and it. choosing was on not his be or

15. institution fees that Regulations Ashfaq area after Uniworld visa. living finds

36. the that 25 in a publications exemptions in

Procedures the of are this from a mid it he with Australia'), student provided, why income Also of from in the Uniworld visa the 8105 living within goals, as that this apparently On obtained instalment Student visa By no he would 1994. fee Regulations July Masters Homesglen when Associate tuition the met Engineer and proposed the the the on visa August is matters his 1999. grant a two (`meet visa valid on up funds visa the not If career of finish of further 560.222. four for genuineness undertaken the a However,
Australia Immigration Consultants and Online Australia Visa Assessments for immigration to Australia